On a more serious note it underscores a lack of evolution within the BJP leadership which is grappling with a serious identity crisis.

Singh is accurate in saying that if India does not watch out it would enter a 'dark alley' by stifling dissent and discouraging honest intellectual reflection over its history's most traumatic phases. One can legitimately describe the book as the proverbial last straw that broke the camel's back but it is a serious illustration of how atrophy has gripped the BJP. It is not enough to coin sincere sounding terms such as 'chintan baithak'. It is more important to actually seriously reflect and ruminate over how the party has lost its way. On top of the agenda should have been to ask why it felt compelled to expel Singh.

An impartial assessment of Jinnah is not going to reverse history, nor is it going to expose the BJP to any political jeopardy in a country where a large majority of its 550 million people below the age of 25 would not know if Jinnah danced in front of them. Some of the BJP leaders need to be brought out of their slumber and reintroduced to the India of 2009. Unless the party repositions itself to the dramatically different realities of now, no amount of 'chintan baithaks' will help reclaim the lost ground. In that context Singh's intellectual inquiries and assessments as an author are hardly an obstacle.

In many ways Singh must feel a sense of liberation now that he is no longer hamstrung by party discipline. India needs serious contrarians who can frequently challenge lazy certainties of established wisdoms. It is a great and powerful role that someone like Singh can fulfill even as he continues to remain in public life.

(20.8.09-Mayank Chhaya is the editor of South Asia Daily in the US. He can be contacted at m@literateworld.com)